Cumberland Farms in New Windsor (405 Blooming Grove Tpk)

I'm a club member and most times this station gas prices for non-members are higher than other area gas stations making the 10¢ off non-existent for members. If there's a discount, it's between 3¢-7¢ off for members compared to area gas prices. Thanks to GasBuddy I can search for cheaper prices.

Friendly staff and competitive prices

Clean

Ok

Prices are right

Never had an issue and that Cumberland is cheaper than the one near me in Middletown. Got gas at 20 cents less including the 10 discount can’t complain

Too small of a gas station

I have the Smartcatd and as far as gas goes I rarely use the 10 cent discount because I can get gas cheaper as other stations that the discount at this station

Good stop always.

easy access. good lighting. excellent convenience store. however, prices have been higher than surrounding stations the last couple of months