Home Gas Price Search Ohio Cincinnati Casey's (539 Old State Route 74)

Casey's in Cincinnati (539 Old State Route 74)

Casey's

Casey's 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 (67)
539 Old State Route 74
CincinnatiOH 
1 (513) 715-2738
Open Now: 09:00AM-05:00AM

Station Prices

Reported Gas Price

The prices in this row are the prices that members of the GasBuddy community provide.

Prices can also come from store owners and retailer data feeds.

These prices are invaluable to helping one another save the most on fuel!

Diesel
UNL88
E85
Premium
Regular
$3.57
Member Icon Owner

54 minutes ago

$2.83
Member Icon Owner

1 hour ago

$2.53
Member Icon Owner

1 hour ago

$3.68
Member Icon Owner

1 hour ago

$2.98
Member Icon Owner

1 hour ago

Log In To Report Prices

Station Ratings

4.1
Overall Rating

Features & Amenities

Air Pump
ATM
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Propane
Restrooms

Reviews

gas23gas's avatar image
gas23gas
Dec 22 2020
Bad Review Icon

Lower quality of gas which is cheaper but not worth it. Poor customer service, rude manager. Lousy big corporation service.

polofields's avatar image
polofields
Jun 30 2024
Bad Review Icon

American Express cards weren’t working after 11pm.

spanky1367's avatar image
spanky1367
Apr 01 2024
Okay Review Icon

Owner reports 91 octane as “premium”. Typically 93 is premium and what my car needs. Cost for 93 is significantly higher than he reports for premium

redgts's avatar image
redgts
Nov 02 2023
Great Review Icon

I'd stop at Casey's while traveling for work. Nice to see one here. Good pump prices.

jmstevens2's avatar image
jmstevens2
Sep 14 2023
Bad Review Icon

Nice

the_wise_walrus's avatar image
the_wise_walrus
Jul 21 2023
Great Review Icon

Mt Caramel Casey’s. Classic Casey’s – clean, lots of pumps, well stocked store,hot food, good service. 

greatcloud's avatar image
greatcloud
Jul 06 2023
Great Review Icon

They advertise bacon, egg and cheese pizza and sausage egg and cheese pizza. I went in there to get some because it’s always supposed to be ready and they said I need to cough. I want bacon, egg and cheese pizza because they end up throwing it out but I guess sausage egg and pizza is what people are looking for well, I would’ve bought several pieces of that bacon, egg and cheese pizza, I should’ve had it ready. I have not gotten a breakfast pizza in over a year from there because of the guy short brown hair. I don’t know his name he’s about 5’6”, and I feel like he was rude

jatkins24's avatar image
jatkins24
May 11 2023
Okay Review Icon

Ok

jorcutt7319's avatar image
jorcutt7319
Dec 15 2022
Great Review Icon

Competitive and convenient!

simbal's avatar image
simbal
Dec 03 2022
Great Review Icon

Great gas prices, so many offerings inside, beer & wine, full grill, fountain, sundries, excellent donuts. Great neighborhood addition!

These reviews are the subjective opinion of a GasBuddy member and not of GasBuddy LLC

Stations Near This Location

Sunoco

Sunoco 
0.05mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarEmpty Star
 60
4514 Mount Carmel Tobasco Rd
Mount Carmel, OH
$2.99
Price Reporter Icon deweesfall6 hours ago

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone
ATM
Beer
Wine

Reviews

Jkjm_BST's avatar image
Jkjm_BST
Dec 22 2019
Great Review Icon

Great customer service! Very nice people. Love coming here.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Speedway

Speedway 
0.46mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 102
621 Batavia Pike
Mount Carmel, OH
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon deweesfall6 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone

Reviews

jatkins24's avatar image
jatkins24
Dec 05 2024
Great Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Marathon 
0.58mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 58
647 Old OH-74
Summerside, OH
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon Valletta1 hour ago

Amenities

C-Store

Reviews

linenrep's avatar image
linenrep
May 06 2017
Great Review Icon

Have diesel fuel


View Full Station Details
 Details
BP

BP 
0.78mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 34
3251 Mount Carmel Rd
Mount Carmel, OH
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon DataFeed30 minutes ago

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
ATM

Reviews

Ramit4me's avatar image
Ramit4me
Feb 09 2020
Okay Review Icon

gas prices are always much higher than nearby locations.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Shell

Shell 
1.19mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 130
4261 Mount Carmel Tobasco Rd
Mount Carmel, OH
$2.99
Price Reporter Icon Buddy_kj5711hr1 minute ago

Amenities

No amenities found.


Reviews

hasopi's avatar image
hasopi
Oct 24 2024
Bad Review Icon

Does not honor fuel rewards


View Full Station Details
 Details